Baseball award season started this week with the announcement of the Gold Glove awards. Derek Jeter won his fifth, igniting a firestorm of criticism because the only things he had in his favor were his fielding percentage and his reputation.
In the National League, Albert Pujols took home the Gold Glove at first base even though at least one columnist thought Ike Davis should have won instead.
Most of the arguments focused on the use of advanced fielding statistics – UZR and Plus/Minus. I’ll admit that the traditional fielding percentage stat is virtually useless since it rewards players with limited range because they are less likely to be charged with errors. But at least it’s easy to explain – (putouts + assists) / (putouts + assists + errors).
UZR and Plus/Minus have to be better metrics of actual fielding ability, but until somebody can explain exactly how they are figured I can’t understand why their proponents expect to see widespread adoption.
Besides, you don’t really need anything more than your own eyes to see that Derek Jeter’s range has greatly diminished or that Ike Davis is a really good first baseman.
Continue reading “Random Thoughts: Gold Gloves, managers, minor league free agents & Jeff Francoeur” →
40.659500
-74.288354